(I don’t know if I should be posting on this sub but it’s the best I found)
The tier list is all the games I’ve 100% and S is “I very much recommend completing” and C is “only do this if your dedicated” (we don’t go near D. I wouldn’t do that to myself.) Some of the big factors is how fun the game is all the way through, how long it takes, and most importantly, how much tedium.
Mario 64 is S+ because it’s very fun, there are no troubles, and it’s short. You won’t have a problem.
Super Mario Bros. Wonder is S because It’s fun. There are little problems. And it’s enjoyable. This game could be S+ but it doesn’t have the same amount of replay value as 64. Still a goated game.
NSMB won’t have that many problems. It might be hard finding all of the secret exits but that’s it.
Kirby’s return to dreamland is a great game all the way through. There are 3 slight issues. 1 is platinuming all 7 (x2) challenges, 2 is playing the game over again, and 3 is the difficulty of the true arena. But these are mainly fun. Return to return is a similar story but with bonus content. You will have to grind more platinums in not just the challenges now but also Magalor’s Epilogue. And even grind the impossible challenges in Merry Magiland.
Super Star is easy. You can trust the 100% on your save. The one problem is how hard the arena is. Just use hammer. Always use hammer.
Mario Land 2 will be a blast. Find all 31 levels and then go for Wario.
Kirby’s adventure is fun but clunky. The switches can be frustrating and the extra game doesn’t have saves so you need to beat it in one go. No tomorrow.
Mario 3D land is fun but you need to play each stage twice and grinding all of the purple boxes takes time so abuse your calendar. Champions road is easy just use rock leaves.
Treasure tracker (WIIU) is the first game I’ve completed. The main problem is playing each normal stage about 4 times and you need the toad amiibo.
TotM is the only indie game here. There is a lot of grinding but just buy this version instead of the crappy mobile version.
Kirby’ dream buffet is a game you have to like and play over and over again. That’s it.
Paper Mario is very fun. Recipes are annoying and learn to use the star piece finder badge. The super boss isn’t too hard.
Kirby and the amazing mirror is great if you know how to track all the rooms you have been in and completed. Make sure every tile is flashing.
A link to the past, Majora’s mask, and Ocarina of time aren’t that hard. Use guides for heart pieces, skultilas, and bottles, etc.. make sure you research all the items and missable items.
Super Mario 3D world is a problem when you realize you need to finish each level with each character. Champions road is actually hard this time too! Bowser’s fury is also amazing.
NSMBW is fun untill you see a Luigi block appear. You can loose save data if you save with that.
Kirby triple deluxe has a few challenges. 1: getting all keychains. 2: Beating the true arena. 3: finishing all 40 levels of Kirby fighters.
I did 3 playthroughs of the Minish cap. Nintendo I want my time back. You will need to collect all of the stupid figurines and do the dumb arrow sidequest. Do all the Zelda stuff I mentioned before and complete all 100 kenstone merging.
Kirby’s dreamland 2 has the dumb rainbow drops. They aren’t even rainbow, they are white and light grey.
Kirby and the forgotten land is down here because it expects you to give your life to it. It’s okay because I love this game to death. Getting what the game claims is 100% and checkmarking everything and getting every ability to +star and getting x9 of most of the figures is crazy.
GGs if you read this all.
Posted by Leakingbag